![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |

|
|
Programme
B3 -
India-The Global Hub: The Onset of Globalization Re-Visited Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
The aim of this session is to re-examine the work done over the last 30 years about India's pivotal role in the process of economic globalisation since 1600. The role of the Dutch East India Company and the English East India will be re-considered, and their role in integrating East Asia into world economic networks via India. In later periods India's central position in international settlement structures will be re-examined, especially in relation to her surpluses with China and Japan, and her deficits with Britain which were so crucial to sustaining the international trade networks created during the era of Free Trade. India's role in linking world grain markets will also be examined, for it was in India that the world wheat market met and integrated with the world rice market, as India produced, consumed and exported both grains. India also had an important and central role in world textile markets, importing textiles from Britain and exporting yarn to China, and raw cotton to Japan. There were many other areas in international economic life in which India played a crucial role, including shipping, railways, and telegraphs. The session will include papers on all these matters, and hopefully other issues not mentioned here. An appeal will be made for papers to augument the papers which have already been agreed. Organizers: • - India - The Global Hub: The Onset of Globalisation Revisited • Heita Kawakatsu Participants: • Kirti N. Chaudhuri • Kumar Das • Murari Jha - Fluidity of Nature and the Rhythms of Navigation along the Ganges in the 18th Century
Abstract • Takashi Kume • Toshiyuki Miyata • J. Forbes Munro - Scotland, India and Globalization: Scottish Merchants in the Trade of Maritime Asia, 1776-1840
The Scottish mercantile presence in Asia in the decades to 1840 had three principal features: • Ghulam Nadri - Early Colonial Experiments with Indian Agriculture: the Case of Indigo Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
When the English and the Dutch East India Companies began trading with western India (Gujarat) in the early seventeenth century, their authorities were most attracted by the prospects of profit in indigo trade. By the third quarter of the seventeenth century, however, a variety of cotton and silk textiles gained primacy in the Companies’ exports from Gujarat. Indigo export to Europe dwindled primarily because of a large supply of trans-Atlantic dye at relatively less costs than the one from South Asia. Its production in India subsequently declined. In the late eighteenth century, the European demand for Indian indigo once again improved substantially. This was largely due to a decline in the supply of American dye to Europe on account of Britain’s loss of colonies in America and the Napoleonic wars and his ‘continental blockade’ of British trade. The EIC, which had taken over the political control of Bengal and had a cleavage in the domain of political authority in western India, took upon it the opportunity to benefit from the rising demand for indigo at home. In order to be able to do so, the Company desperately tried to push up the output of indigo in South Asia. • R.L. Sahoo - "The Growth of Cotton Mills in Western India and Colonial Economic Policy, 1854-1894". The cotton textile mill industries has been accredited as the fore-runner of industrialisation in India. They occupied a vital place in the Indian economy and contributed substantially towards employment generation and revenues. With the introduction of modern cotton mills in 1854, India entered a new phase of industrialisation . As the economic and political destiny of India was then governed by colonial rulers, the state of economic development was subject to imperial aims. This paper aims to shed light on how the establishment of cotton textile mills marked a departure from the earlier colonial policy of not allowing machine industries in India. In examining the circumstances under which the cotton textile mills were set up in western India during the second half of the nineteenth century, the paper focuses on the impact of globalization, and the opportunities and challenges faced by Indian entrepreneurs, the role played by British capitalists and colonial economic policy. It also discusses the contribution of English entrepreneurs and technicians in the growth of the cotton textile mills during the four decades covered in this paper. Under colonial rule the industrial development in India was stunted and subordinated to the interests of the British capitalist class. The paper examines whether the formulation of British commercial policy vis-à-vis the setting up of the cotton textile mill industry in India was purely dictated by Lancashire interests or if it was at times modified by the prevailing political situation in India. • Ryuto Shimada - Invisible Links: Maritime Trade between Japan and India in the Early Modern Period Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide In the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, Japan had significant economic links with India. It was realized by the trading business of the Dutch East India Company (VOC). The VOC succeeded not only in the Euro-Asian trade but also in the intra-Asian trade, both of which contributed to the huge amount of the profits for the Dutch Company. The paper examines the significance of the triangular trade between Japan, India and South East Asia, which was the largest trading pattern in scale and profitability in the intra-Asian trade of the VOC. The analysis of this research is mainly based on unpublished data sources collected from the archives of the VOC kept in the national Archives of the Netherlands in combination with Japanese records. • Chisako Tsuji - The East India Company in 1813: The Loss of Its Monopoly on Indian Trade Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
This paper mainly discusses the loss of the monopoly of Indian Trade in 1813 by the East India Company, the entity which was undergoing a major transition period in the early 19th century. The paper examines how British people in the area perceived Indian society controlled by the company, how they attempted to solve problems appearing in that society and how they eventually concerned themselves with the abolition of the company’s monopoly in 1813. The paper, therefore, focuses on the following two issues. First, it studies the reaction of the central government of the United Kingdom, where all the policy decisions were made. The paper examines for what purposes the parties concerned with the central government conducted political activities concerning the monopoly issue, referring to preceding studies. Second, the paper discusses Robert Rickards, a British government official stationed in India. He was not directly engaged in Indian trade, and was away from his home country. Why he became involved in the issue of monopoly will be clarified in this paper through the examination of his Memorials and papers. C3 -
Foreign minorities and business development in Latin America (19th and 20th centuries ) Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
The purpose of this symposium is to study, since different points of views, foreign minorities’ insertion in the labour market and their role in the formation of the companies en Latin America. The importance of foreign investments (particularly in mining, railroads and petrol) in the economic development of countries as Argentina, Brazil, Peru or México is known. Meanwhile, we ignore almost everything about the firms created by emigrants in these and other American countries which should be considered as “national firms” and whose contribution to de economic development of these territories and to the creation of a “managerial spirit” has not been already balanced. We want to put our attention in these small firms born in Latin America and owned by emigrants, since we think that their study could offer new explanations of the economic opportunities in underdevelopment countries, the European migrations and the business culture of Latin America in a historical perspective. Organizers: • - Inmigrantes estadounidenses y tejido empresarial en el noroeste de México. 1860-1930. Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide El trabajo que no ocupa tiene por objeto revisar las características de la actividad desarrollada y el papel jugado por algunos empresarios de origen estadounidense en los procesos de innovación y modernización de la producción agrícola en el norte de Sinaloa, en los finales del siglo XIX principios del XX. Intentaremos responder a las preguntas de cuándo, cómo y porqué estos hombres de negocios no sólo se arriesgaron ante la perspectiva de pérdidas en proyectos productivos, sino que asumieron la incertidumbre de obtener ganancias que ellos conllevaban, al establecerse por primera vez en una región sobre la cual se tenía aún poco conocimiento de casos similares. Podemos afirmar que estos empresarios fueron promotores y protagonistas de un desarrollo económico regional indudable, cuyas consecuencias se pueden apreciar aún hoy en día. • Javier Moreno Lázaro - SPANISH WORKERS AND EMPLOYERS IN MEXICO IN 1930. THE STATE OF PUEBLA: A QUANTITATIVE APPROACH La española en México, con ser desde su independencia la que conformaba la comunidad extranjera más nutrida y política y socialmente más influyente, ha sido desatendida por lo historiografía a uno y otro lado del océano, en el caso de la mexicana, seducida por otras minorías con logros económicos más vistosos, y en de la española, disuadida de su estudio por la menor importancia cuantitativa de la emigración a ese país. Es más, el análisis en perspectiva histórica de la presencia española en México se ha vertebrado en torno a la premisa de la “inmigración privilegiada”, formulada sin sustento cuantitativo alguno. En virtud de este apriorismo, al español le esperaba a su llegada a México un éxito económico seguro (en el peor de los casos, como abarrotero). La ausencia de proletarización entre los españoles y la nula integración de la mujer en el mercado de trabajo son los correlatos de tal tesis, tan extendida como falaz. Mi propósito en este trabajo es refutar tal tesis y proporcionar, al tiempo, una primera aproximación cuantitativa de la composición de la fuerza laboral española en México. Para ello, he empleado fuentes españolas y elegido como ámbito de estudio el Estado de Puebla, como tendré ocasión de demostrar, uno de los de mayor presencia hispana. He elegido el año de 1930, a medio camino entre el fin de la guerra de la guerra cristera y el comienzo de la depresión que sufrió la economía mexicana durante la primera mitad de la década de los treinta. Este es justamente el año escogido por Gamboa (1994) en su pionero estudio sobre los españoles afincados en Puebla, que asume algunas de las consideraciones en torno a la situación económica de los inmigrantes de este origen que pretendo matizar. Al tiempo, pretendo sopesar y determinar las causas del éxito económico de algunos ciudadanos españoles que sí alcanzaron la prosperidad gracias a la creación de empresas en Puebla. Participants: • Silvia Badoza - Origins and expansion of a big company: Compañía General de Fósforos, 1889-1929 Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
This article studies the history of Compañía General de Fósforos, one of the first industrial stock companies in Argentina, during its forty years of existence, from 1889 to 1929. We aim at analizing the company's productive and finantial strategies, based on a research using the company archives. • Claudio Belini • Guyonne Blanchy - The impact and influence of the French in the development of Mendoza, Argentina's wine industry at the end of the 19th century The impact and influence of the French in the development of Mendoza, Argentina's wine industry at the end of the 19th century. This topic represents a portion of my phd research. How can a minority play a role in business development? This is the problem I address by examining the French's creation of a modern and capitalist vineyard, achieved through regional specialization, business development, and influence of a minority: French people (knowledge, entreprenneurs, capital) • Mario Contreras - De Inmigrantes a elite empresarial regional de Tepic, siglo XIX Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide En esta ponencia se identifica y caracteriza el grupo empresarial que se forjó en una región del occidente de México y que tenía en común, en principio su extranjería; europea. Las ideas centrales que guían esta propuesta son las siguientes: a) la actividad empresarial desarrollada por los extranjeros llevó a una mayor articulación de la economía productiva de la región, b) la actividad empresarial imprimió un ritmo a la economía local a un nivel que no tenía precedente, y c) ese grupo empresarial definió un proyecto de autonomía política en la región que lo consiguió con éxito. • María de Jesús López - Inmigrantes griegos en la agricultura del valle de Culiacán 1948-1970 Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide En el trabajo se analizan las actividades empresariales llevadas a cabo por los inmigrantes griegos en el Valle de Culiacán, ya que estos se dedicaron fundamentalmente a la explotación de la agricultura comercial en la región. Sin ser una comunidad numerosa desempeñaron un papel sobresaliente en la producción de hortalizas. En 1948 el 38 por ciento de la cosecha de legumbres en Sinaloa fue exportada por extranjeros, en sus cuatro quintas partes de origen griego. • Alonso Martínez Barreda - Inversionistas extranjeros en Sinaloa, 1870-1920 Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
El objetivo del presente trabajo es analizar las diversas actividades que se desarrollaron en Sinaloa, a partir del periodo de gobierno del Gral. Francisco Cañedo, mismo que dará continudad en el periodo de revolución armada de 1910 - 1920. El arribo de diversos capitales extranjeros posibilitaron la consolidación de tres importantes polos de desarrollo económico (Ahome, Culiacán y Mazatlán), impulsándose actividades como el comercio, la industria, agricultura, mineria, mismas que marcaran los ejes centrales de la economía • Francisco Suárez Viera - “Canarian businessmen in Cuba, 1850-1950” Canarian emigration to Cuba during the modern era has been commonly regarded as a phenomenon dominated by the farmer, a man who emigrated to work in the country either as a tenant in a large property or as day laborers, contributing decisively to social and economic development of the island. This is an incomplete intrepretation, Canarians performed in a wide range of activities in Cuba, both in the country and in the city, and they were not strange to company ventures. In this article we will approach the latter aspect that thanks to recent studies provide new nuances on the great migration of canarians, a side that had already been well studied for other groups such as Asturians or Catalans in Cuba. Islanders entrepreneurs contributed to the building of the Cuban business community with the creation and development of a wide range of businesses from small farmers to owners of sugar refineries and multinational trade enterprises. First we will look at the socioeconomic context of the canarian migration and then continued to expose the most important aspects of business development involving Islander migrants. D3 -
Regulation and deregulation in the public utilities from the 19th Century to today Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
Can capitalism live without regulation? It seems that many economists believe it can. Some elaborated theories to support their point of view thereby reducing regulation to a politically motivated practice. However, attempts from the 1970s to deregulate didn't match their expectations. What was meant to be deregulation turned out to be a new and more complex REregulation. Privatisation, which was supposed to go hand in hand with deregulation, finally demanded its own regulation. Even nationalised companies were put under the surveillance of newly created regulatory agencies. Organizers: • - From socialism to liberalism: regulation and deregulation of electricity in Brazil, China and India. Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
This paper will examine the efficiency of regulation in the electrical sector of three emerging countries, Brazil, China and India. Since the last two decades, there have been new sets of regulation (in the electrical industry, the concept “deregulation” is usually used to mention the changes which occurred; however, it doesn’t describe adequately the nature of these changes) in these countries in order to make their respective electrical sectors more compatible with similar regulation adopted in the developed countries. Two goals are pursued with this new regulation: 1- to increase efficiency in the production and especially the distribution of electricity; 2- to create a more favourable environment for FDI. • Judith Catherine Clifton - The Importance of Being Late: Internationalization Patterns of Telecoms Incumbents
Policies to liberalize, deregulate, and privatise the telecommunications sector by most governments around the world from the 1980s dramatically changed the comfortable post-war environment in which incumbents had previously existed. The opening up of formerly closed domestic markets enabled incumbent players to evaluate the attractiveness and feasibility of an internationalization project. Many European incumbents opted to venture abroad. But why did some firms have more success in their internationalization efforts whilst others failed? This paper seeks to explain the extent of internationalization of these firms. • Harm G. Schröter Participants: • Jean-François Auger • Dominique Barjot • Martin Chick - Regulation, Risk and Responsibility: The 3 Rs and the Utilities in Britain since 1945. This paper examines the attempts of governments in Britain to improve the efficiency of resource allocation to and in the main utility industries since 1945. As well as exploring the growing interest in the 1950s and 1960s in developing the use of Required Rates of Return and then Test Discount Rates in the nationalised industries, it also traces the growing interest in breaking these industries into their competitive and natural monopoly components. In analysing the familiar disappointment at the favouring of the transfer of ownership over the introduction of competition in the early privatisations, the paper also examines how regulators sought to address a new problem faced by utilities eventually subject to competition, namely how to provide sufficient incentives and assurance of future returns so as to stimulate long-term investment programmes in these industries. • Francisco Comín • Daniel Diaz-Fuentes - Phases in Public Service Regulation in Spain: Telecommunications and electricity and postal services Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
Regulation is a determining factor as regards the progress or otherwise of an economy. Though regulation is not the only variable that influences the economy, good regulation favours economic growth, whilst poor regulation can slow the economy down. Analysing regulation is complex due to the fact that various sectors of an economy have different characteristics, whilst the agents involved in the design and implementation of regulation are motivated by self-interest. In addition, there is a scarcity of objective indicators to measure regulation and compare its evolution across economies. • Patrick Fridenson • Renato Giannetti • William J. Hausman • Pierre Jambard - The French housing market: an original example of regulation of an almost public utility (1950-1970) France of the 1950-1960's offered a very interesting example of an implementation of a housing market, almost completly regulated by the State and the public institutions. After the II World War, very voluntary legal and financial measures organized this market, without taking ideology in consideration. • Erik Lindberg • Kenneth Lipartito • Charles-François Mathis - Regulation of water supply in Great-Britain in the 19th century Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide The building of huge reservoirs in the 19th century by industrial towns such as Glasgow, Manchester, Liverpool or Birmingham, did raise many questions concerning the regulation which should be applied to these undertakings. The movement of municipalisation admittedly dramatically improved the quantity and quality of water supplied, but it did not exclude market mechanisms and had thus to be submitted to a national regulation. Indeed, a competition between towns took place, which Parliament did its best to supervise and refrain. Conflicting public interests were often at stake, and Parliament had to arbitrate between them, notably on broad environmental questions such as compensation, commons rights or landscape preservation, on which the study will focus. • Michèle Merger • Robert Millward - Geo-politics versus Market Structure Interventions in Europe's Infrastructure Industries c.1830-1939
I have argued in recent publications that it is a mistake to attribute differences across countries (Europe, USA and Japan) in business-state relationships simply to ideological stances: strategic and technological factors are also important. Throughout the 19th and 20th centuries, the natural monopoly features of infrastructure industries have been an important element and often a common feature of state intervention. The aim of this paper is to evaluate what relative weight was attached to such market failure problems on the one hand and geo-political factors on the other. For the period 1830-1939, how far were geo-political factors stronger than natural monopoly problems in accounting for the scale of intervention in the various countries of the Western World? How far did the policy instruments for security and market failure overlap? Whilst most of the infrastructure sectors are covered – including internal telecommunications, coal, gas, shipping, electricity and water – special attention is devoted to international submarine telegraph tables and railways. The paper concludes by demonstrating strong differences between Britain and USA on the one hand and Continental Europe plus Japan on the other. • Julio Revuelta • Esa Ruuskanen - Substitute for Oil: Public Subsidies for the Use of Peat as a Fuel in Nordic Countries after the First Oil Crisis
The aim of this study is to elucidate the co-evolution of the national policies on energy, environment and competitiveness in global markets in Nordic Countries after the First Oil Crisis. After the oil crises of the 1970s, the use of peat fuel as a substitute for crude oil was championed by the Finnish and Swedish governments. Notwithstanding the high CO2 emission factor of peat fuel, the Finnish, Swedish and Estonian government’s future strategies for both district heating and electricity generation rely partly on the use of peat as a fuel. It is difficult to alter policies that have been dictated by previous complex circumstances. • Pierangelo Toninelli - Post WW2 tariffs regulation in Italy: the case of electricity
Abstract. Price regulation has been a traditional device of Italian government intervention in production and distribution of electricity. The pillars of this intervention were essentially two: i) to make prices correspond to the generation and distribution costs on the basis of end-users’ different consumption and ii) to use electricity tariffs as a tool for macroeconomic interventions: for instance tariffs were frozen several times in order to curb inflation. E3 -
Arrighi in Beijing. A roundtable on Giovanni Arrighi's 'Adam Smith in Beijing. Lineages of the twenty-first century' Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
In 2007 Giovanni Arrighi published his long expected analysis of shifting global powers in the twenty-first century. In his 'The Long Twentieth Century. Money, Power, and the Origins of Our Times' (1994) Arrighi presented a powerful account of the alternating hegemonic cycles within the expanding capitalist world economy since the 13th century. Adam Smith in Beijing completes the story, describing and explaining the fast retreat of the 20th century hegemonic power, the US, and the formation of an 'East-Asian-centred world-market'. As the book argues, 'in the 21st century China may well become again the kind of non-capitalist market economy that Smith described, under totally different domestic and world-historical conditions.' Organizer: • - What remains of the capitalist world-system? A review essay on Giovanni Arrighi’s intellectual trajectory This review essay evaluates the new road Giovanni Arrighi is paving in Adam Smith in Beijing (2007), both with regards to his own intellectual trajectory within the field of World-Systems Analysis as to the scholarly debate on Europe's nineteenth-century Great Divergence from the rest of the world and the present outcomes of this process. The central analytical argument of Adam Smith in Beijing is that the probability has increased that we are witnessing the formation of an “East Asian-centered world-market society” rivaling the historical “capitalist world-economy”. The central political message is that this change in the nature of the global world-economy might bring about a Great Convergence to the commonwealth of civilizations that Adam Smith foresaw. Both propositions force Giovanni Arrighi to get China (a totum pro parte for East Asia) into the world-historical equation, past and future. Most reviews so far have zoomed in on Arrighi’s political message and have criticized his characterization of China as a non-capitalist society and his views on the potential benign role that China could play in the wider world. We focus primarily on the analytical side of the story and show how Arrighi’s discovery of East-Asia has led him to supplement the analysis of historical capitalism he presented in The Long Twentieth Century (1994) and to un-think World-Systems Analysis. This brings about uncertainties and problems. On the one hand, Arrighi is clear in his view on the different paths of economic development that the European capitalist world-system and the Chinese-centered market-oriented world-system walked down deep into the nineteenth century. On the other hand, he is less clear on how the Asian market-oriented legacy survived its incorporation into the globalizing capitalist world-system, a crucial precondition for his political message. Characterized as a process of subordination, hybridization or fusion, it remains hard to get an unambiguous understanding of the place of China and East Asia within the world-system. It is just as hard to understand the nature of that “interstitial” system itself. There is a world in singular, denoted as “world capitalism”, “world market” or “world-trading system” and there are worlds in plural (such as the Global North and Global South). All these conceptual and theoretical uncertainties add up to the central question that hangs over Adam Smith in Beijing: What remains of the capitalist world-system as an analytical category that allows us to understand the economic history and future? Participants: • Patrick O'Brien - Panel member and discussant • Kenneth Pomeranz • Kaoru Sugihara • Peer Vries F3 -
The World in 2030. Educated guesses from a long-run perspective Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
1. Motivation Organizer: • Participants: • Kyoji Fukao • Timothy Hatton • Peter H. Lindert - The Welfare State in 2030 Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
Demography, growth prospects, and politics together determine which countries will have social spending crises by 2030. Some simple algebra suggests which countries will have the most trouble preventing a decline in real benefit levels while also preventing tax-rate increases. Those most at risk are not the welfare states of Northern and Western Europe, whose high-spending programs have avoided any clear growth effects. Rather the well-known age trends and approximate growth prospects predict the greatest trouble for much of Latin America and the Caribbean, Switzerland, New Zealand, four East European countries, and South Africa. The big-trouble club might also include Japan and the Asian Tigers if their growth rates fall as far as Angus Maddison is predicting. • Debin Ma - The Question of China’s Size: Historical Origin and Future Implications Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide One striking and alluring feature of Chinese economy is her sheer size. It is also the world’s single longest surviving civilization with a continuous history, unified by one common language and characterized by an unusually high degree of ethnic homogeneity for her size. This paper surveys and speculates on the broad questions of the institutional, geographic and historical origin of her size as well as the future implications for both China’s and the world economy. Historically, the scaling-up of China is a response to the invasion and absorption of the nomads largely from the North. This historical pattern of response led to a structure of political dominance centered in Northern China. However, by mid-19th century, the European colonial challenge initiated from the Southern coast drastically restructured the regional dynamics in China. Economic growth in East Asia had overall proceeded along an East-West axis (initiated from the spin-off political units of Chinese civilization such as Taiwan, HK, Korea and to certain degree, Japan). Economic reform in contemporary China along similar geographic and political trajectory led to rapid economic growth but with alarmingly large regional differences also along a East-West direction. While China’s highly centralized political system had done reasonably well in achieving hard growth target during the past three decades of reform, it may find it increasingly difficult to realize genuine welfare improvements difficult to measure by hard figures. Given the huge size and regional diversity, the model of peaceful political transition as had happened in Korea and Taiwan may also be far more difficult to apply to China.While a huge advantage for China, her size also poses a huge challenge to both the Chinese and World economy in 2030 in the two decades to come. • Angus Maddison - The World Economy in 2030: A Quantitative Assessment • Kevin O'Rourke - Power and Plenty in 2030 Globalization is as much a political, and geopolitical, phenomenon as it is a technological one. It follows that the future of globalization will largely depend on geopolitical trends. This paper speculates about those trends, about possible scenarios for the future, and about ways in which the current crisis may influence which of those scenarios will arise. Contingency and the importances of political choices are stressed throughout. • Leandro Prados de la Escosura - Latin America from independence to 2030: growing up, falling behind, but catching up? Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
When did Latin America fall behind? Has the gap between Core and Latin America widened over the long run? Is high inequality a permanent feature of modern Latin America’s history? Have trends in growth and inequality had a long-run effect on poverty reduction? What are the main challenges Latin America faces in the early 21st century?, are major topics in Latin American economic history. Some tentative answers can now be provided: • Paul Rhode - The World in 2030. Educated guesses about the Environment from a long-run perspective Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide This paper contributes to the panel "The World in 2030. Educated guesses from a long-run perspective" by exploring expected changes in world-wide environmental conditions. It investigates anticipated changes associated with global warming including rising temperatures, sea levels, and the prospects for a large wave of extinctions. It also details recent discussions of "peak oil," the "end of food," and recurrent water shortages. Finally, it evaluates the historical accuracy of past forecasts regarding the environment and considers ways to go forward. • Osamu Saitō - Japan in 2030: prospects and problems of a service economy after the age of industrialisation Japan’s economic history since the Meiji Restoration of 1868 is characterised by alternating phases of less conspicuous growth performance in pre-war times, phenomenal growth of the 1955-73 period, and marked deceleration thereafter. The deceleration since 1973 is so dramatic and prolonged that Angus Maddison has recently placed Japan’s growth outlook for the future in one of the lowest performing groups in the world. Japan’s rate of growth of per-capita GDP from 2003 to 2030 is predicted at 1.3 per cent per annum as against 1.7 per cent for other countries in the ‘rich’ group and the world average of 2.23 per cent. This paper suggests that while post-war Japan’s ‘super’ growth was associated with an exceptionally high productivity growth in manufacturing, the recent rise of a service economy is not. In the 1955-73 period, Japanese manufacturing firms developed a system under which unprecedented capital deepening was compatible with a skill-using mode of shop-floor relations. We argue, therefore, that unless a new, promising regime of productivity growth would emerge in the expanding service sector Japan’s outlook for the early twenty-first century would not be very bright. • Jeffrey Gale Williamson - Will Third World Emigration Rates Drop Off by 2030?
This paper documents a stylized fact: the Third World has been undergoing an emigration life cycle since the 1960s, and, except for Africa, emigration rates reached a peak in the late 1980s and the early 1990s. The current economic crisis will serve only to accelerate downward trends from that peak. The paper estimates the economic and demographic fundamentals driving these emigration life cycles -- income and education gaps between the US and the sending country, poverty traps and the size of the cohort at risk in the sending country, and the foreign-born stock in the US. It then projects the life cycle twenty years hence. The projections imply that pressure on Third World emigration will not increase, but rather will most likely decline. It also suggests that future US immigrants will be much more African and much less Hispanic than in the past. G3 -
Why is economic history not an evolutionary science? Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
Economic history is dominated by two opposite approaches that can be roughly defined as either quantitative or qualitative. Each of these approaches receives criticism from the other side. Not seldom, the analytical results of either of these approaches differ fundamentally, which is a clear sign of the insufficient explanatory power of both quantitative and qualitative research techniques. Organizers: • - Why is economic history not an evolutionary science? Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide Economic history is dominated by two opposite approaches that can be roughly defined as either quantitative or qualitative. Each of these receives criticism from the other side. Not seldomly, the analytical results of either of these approaches differ fundamentally, which is a clear indication of the insufficient explanatory power of both the quantitative and the qualitative research techniques. Economists have long been aware of this discrepancy between the 'closed' positivist, a-historical neoclassical and the 'open' process-focused, history friendly evolutionary and institutional view. Ever since Veblen has asked why economics is not an evolutionary science, his views got considerable attention from economists and other social scientists; yet, we have to recognise that, after a century of Veblen's intervention, the positivist dogma still prevails in much of standard economics. Darwinian thinking (which Veblen has called for) is largely absent in contemporary economics. This, we argue, is equally true in contemporary economic history. In this paper we introduce an evolutionary approach to economic history. Building on a unified rule approach, major methodological, analytical and theoretical issues of quantitative and qualitative research will be discussed in general, and a historical data set on maritime shipping will be (re-)assessed in particular. We present an evolutionary analytical approach of doing historical research and we explain why this approach is necessary for the development of economic history as a scientific discipline. • Kurt Dopfer Participants: • Koen Frenken - Evolutionary Economic Geography: historical contingencies in the location of industries Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide Evolutionary economic geography (Boschma and Frenken 2006) is a new approach in economic geography that explains the location of industry from local processes of cumulative causation. In this, it differs from mainstream economic geography that explains the location of industries from price differentials across locations, and it differs from institutional economic geography that explains the location of industries from institutional differentials across locations. A number of recent studies on the car industry, the banking industry and the fashion design industry carried out at our institute showed that cumulative causation processes are not so much driven by agglomeration externalities (benefits that firm enjoy from co-location) but more so by spin-offs, which cause spatial clustering to take place as employees start new firms in the same location as the parent firm. This insight opens up a genealogical research programme at the firm level. In the paper, we review the studies done so far. We then argue that such an approach offers a platform for interdisciplinary research among geographers, economists, demographers, biologists and historians. We finally outline the contours of such a research program and list a number of research questions that may guide such an endevaour. • Joel Mokyr - Evolution, Culture, and Economic History Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
In recent years economists have become increasingly aware of the role of “culture” in economic development (Tabellini, 2007, 2008; Guiso, Sapienza and Zingales, 2005; Greif 2009). Models of cultural transmission have been developed, in which culture is being imparted either by vertical transmission (from parents to children) or by horizontal or oblique transmission (Bisin and Verdier, 2002). The interest that economic historians should have in these processes seems obvious enough, yet despite the consensus that it is now “kosher” to speak of culture (Temin, 1997), there has been little direct work that tries to use this new interest by economists in culture to bridge between the work in cultural history and the many questions that come up in economic history. • Jack Vromen • Ulrich Witt - Explaining the Evolution of Consumption Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
It is generally accepted now that innovations are a core element in explaining the long-term transformations of modern economies and their unprecedented growth over the past few centuries. Innovations generate advances in production technology by which the productivity of the resources is increased and production costs are lowered. Innovations also allow to improve and differentiate the goods and services supplied and to create entirely new ones. While the productivity-driven income increases generated at the supply side are quite well understood, the explanation of the demand-side conditions that make people spend ever more on consumption in real terms is at best fragmentary. H3 -
Between Empire and Nation States: Continuity and Change in the Economies of the Middle East and North Africa in the 20th Century Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
The Middle East passed through two great transitions in the 20th Century: The demise of the Ottoman Empire and its replacement by European rule over a good part of the region in the aftermath of WWI, and the post WWII transition from foreign rule to statehood. These transitions should serve as useful anchors for comparatively examining dimensions of continuity and change in the economies of the greater Middle East (including North Africa, which was partially dominated by European powers already in the 19th Century) over the period concerned. Organizers: • • Sevket Pamuk Participants: • Devrim Dumludag - An Economy in Transition: Izmir (1918 – 1938) This study attempts to examine the continuity and change from Ottoman Empire to Turkish republic in terms of economic policies and economic conditions through focusing on Izmir (Smyrna) province for the period 1918 and 1938. The aim of the study is to integrate Ottoman-Turkish urban history into the study of economic history. • Gad Gilbar - Paradigms of Middle Eastern Entrepreneurship in the 19th and 20th Centuries
"The economic pedominance paradigm" has been one of the prevalent generalizations in the historiography of the late Ottoman Empire. According to this paradigm economic entrepreneurship, foreign trade and banking were almost exclusively in the hands of Greek and Armenian Ottoman subjects as well as foreign merchant houses and investors. It has been emphasized that Muslims did not have a share in the more dynamic sectors of the economy. During the twentieth century two additional generalizations regardind the economic role and position of Muslims evolved, namely "the ethnic division of labour paradigm and "the Politics of Notables theory". These paradigms/theories had great impact on Middle Eastern economic historiography in the last decades of the previous century. • Karen Pfeifer - “Social Structures of Accumulation” Theory for the Arab World:
The theory of “social structures of accumulation” was developed to explain long swings of alternating expansion and stagnation in Western capitalist economies, the United States in particular. The strength of SSA analysis is in interpreting the movement of economic history and social transformation as the product of the interaction between a changing external context and shifting internal dynamics. The analysis periodizes the blossoming of sets of institutions into frameworks for economic growth (or, more specifically, capitalist accumulation) that are viable for some years after a crisis has ruptured the previous framework. Within each SSA, however, internal contradictions gradually move to the fore and, often interacting with external pressures, feed into a new era of crisis. After some struggle among social forces, a successful reformulation of institutions into another framework for accumulation emerges, which resolves that crisis and manages those contradictions while planting the seeds for potential future contradictions internal to the dynamics of the new SSA. • Relli Shechter - The Cultural Economy of Development in Egypt The article presents a new overview on economic transition in Egypt, emphasizing the role of culture in shaping its recent economic history. Since partial independence, and culminating in the heyday of the Nasserite regime, 'economic nationalism' became a predominant national identity mark and a concept central to a local sense of authenticity. The article discusses the meaning of economic nationalism and why it turned such a powerful symbol of Egyptianness. The prevalence of this idea slowed down a transformation to an alternative economic regime when the development effort associated with economic nationalism partially failed. Instead, a huge and unregulated ('hidden') economy emerged, together with a corollary local consumer society. Fiercely resisted in a public discourse captivated by an older economic imagination, both have still shaped the Egyptian economy ever since. • Yucel Terzibasoglu - Land Reform in the post-Ottoman geography: the Balkans, Anatolia, and the Middle East at the turn of the 20th century Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
This paper will explore the place and impact of the Ottoman land regime in the land reform movements and property regimes established by different states in the former provinces of the Empire in the Balkans, in Anatolia and in the Middle East at the beginning of the 20th century. It will first analyse the long term consequences of the Ottoman land reform of the second half of the 19th century in these three regions. This will involve an explanation of the main aims of and expectations from the new land regime established gradually in the Empire in the second half of the 19th century, its implementation in different provinces of the Empire and the varying consequences of reform in these regions. Then secondly, it will contextualise the land reform movements and debates in the post-Ottoman nation-states through an analysis of the debates around the agrarian question and the legacy of the Ottoman land regime. In this it will look at the relationship of land reform to population movements; land distribution (and re-distribution) and registration policies followed by different states; and the new property regimes established by the independent states in the Balkans in the late 19th century and the mandate regimes in the Middle East in the aftermath of the First World War. • Massimiliano Trentin - “Die pragmatische Politik des improvisierten Sozialismus” The GDR advisors in Syria, 1965-1972
After political independence in 1946, debates arose in Syria over which patterns of development the country should take, as well as which foreign experience could be accounted as a suitable reference: most of the political élites still related to the Western Europe. However, after recovering from the ruins of WWII and enforcing speedy patterns of growth and industrialization, the socialist states offered themselves as alternative models for development and postcolonial states. The German Democratic Republic played a significant role in the Middle East that was quite peculiar to it. Excluded from any direct military engagement abroad, it could focus foreign intervention on two key-fields: technological and capital transfer and vocational training for political and administrative elites. The rise in power of the Ba’th Party in 1963 favoured the GDR in transferring its organizational models for state-building. For the time being, centralization of power in state-building process and political rationality attached to industrial growth were some of the core features of the Ba’thist reforms. The GDR contributed by sending several advisors both at technical and ministerial levels: most of their suggestions were later translated into law and partially shaped the new Syrian regime and the related state power (Staatsmacht). However, their contributions were deeply affected by Syrian domestic dynamics: the nationalizations in 1965, the June 1967 defeat, power dualism (izdiwajiyyat is sultah) and the eventual success of Hafiz al Assad and his “Corrective Movement”. The paper will offer an insight on the theories as well as the actual practices concerning the GDR consultacy from 1965 to 1972 when reforms and counter-reforms followed quickly and set many of the most enduring features of the Syrian regime. I3 -
Self-seeking or Developmental: the Role of Industry Associations Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
Business history, under the shadow of Alfred Chandler, has focused primarily upon the development and performance of individual, often large scale, corporations through their internal structures and strategies. A shift in emphasis towards a closer understanding of the ways in which firms have historically built capabilities through inter-organisational relationships is warranted. While there is an historical literature on bi-lateral joint ventures, informal networks, and transient single issue arrangements, we know much less about broader industry-wide associations representing the key firms in an industry and spanning their interests in such matters as infrastructure, coordination, dispute mediation, training, and procedural development. Organizers: • - The Developmental Role of Wool Industry Associations in Australia and New Zealand We use evidence from the Australian and New Zealand wool industries to investigate the motives of industry associations. While conventional wisdom assigns rent-seeking motives to such organisations we find that associations can also play a broader beneficial developmental role, which in this case concerns the establishment and expansion of a local commodity market in wool from the late nineteenth century. • Mark Casson - Trade Associations: Theoretical Issues and Evidence from the United Kingdom Participants: • Francesca Carnevali - Social capital, local politics and trade associations in nineteenth century America • Thomas David - Networks of Coordination. Swiss Business Associations as an Intermediary between Business, Politics and Administration during the 20th Century
Until the 1990s, Switzerland could be classified as either a corporatist, cooperative or coordinated market economy where non-market mechanisms of coordination among economic and political actors played a major role in the organization of the economy. In this respect, business interest associations (BIAs) played a key role in terms of coordination and cooperation among the large Swiss companies. First, they favored the flow of information among enterprises, helping to consolidate self-regulation of economic sectors within a very broad legal framework. Second, given the context of a decentralized State and the weakness of political parties at the national level, business interest groups, being highly organized, were very involved in the political decision-making processes at the federal level. BIAs could thus be regarded as intermediary organizations, which functioned like brokers in networks. • David De Vries - Zionist Capitalists: The Diamond Manufacturers' Association in Pre-State Palestine Built on a traditional Jewish occupational niche and driven by the needs of the battle against Nazi Germany the know-how and craft practices of diamond-cutting were transferred in the late 1930s and early 1940s from Antwerp and Amsterdam to Netanya and Tel Aviv. The transplantation, in which British imperial interests and De Beers' cartel practices played a formative role, harbored a tension. On the one hand the colonial power, the cartel and Zionist entrepreneurs made certain that diamond manufacturing would be Jewish-only, organized as a monopolistic manufacturers association and based on an ethnic-trust system. On the other hand traditional diamond-production practices were adapted and harnessed to Zionist state-building interests of social engineering and regimentation, thus challenging a long-standing and borderless immigrants’ craft culture. Through the making of the diamond manufacturers association in Palestine the paper seeks to examine both the centrality of the colonial state in the empowerment of private capital, and the inseparability of association from Zionist state building during a period of war, national conflict and transformation of Empire. • Piotr Franaszek - The National Oil Society and its activity promoting progress in the Galician oil industry at the turn of the 19th century
Statistics on the world oil output in the latter part of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th show an overwhelming domination by the USA. At the same time, there were three important producers of crude oil in Europe: Russia, Rumania and Austro-Hungary - specifically its northern province called Galicia which was the part of Poland annexed by Austria in 1772. Galicia was considerably less industrialized than the other regions of the Austro-Hungary Monarchy. The profound social and economic backwardness was the outstanding feature of Galicia. Unlike the rest of the pattern, Galician oil production was among the highest in the world. With the development of oil mining, Galicia also became one of the leading countries in the field of technology and technical progress in oil mining. Of special significance was the modernization of the so-called Canadian drilling method and brand new solutions in the so-called wash drilling. • Claire Lemercier - Chambres syndicales in Nineteenth-century Paris. Exploring the diversity of industry associations in a specific national and local context
This paper draws on recent international scholarship a. stressing the multifonctional nature of industry association, and especially their role in mitigating overcompetition and providing services to small firms; and b. discussing conditions leading (or not leading) to the creation and success of such collective institutions. • Stephen Morgan - The role of industry and publishing networks in the diffusion of western management knowledge in China before 1949 Chinese managers and business leaders before 1949 were far better informed about the latest advances in Western management knowledge than past scholarship would have us believe. Professional and industry associations played a major role in the diffusion of knowledge about accounting, economics and industry management. By the early 1930s there were associations for accountants, economists, engineers, personnel managers, and specialist lobbies such as the China Institute for Scientific Management. In Shanghai these associations brought together entrepreneurs, managers, business academics, government officials, along with leading publishers, authors, editors and translators of major foreign works on all the major business topics of the day. The paper draws on a bibliographic database of business publications and membership lists of selected associations to map the network ties and social relations of those involved in publishing and promoting ideas about management organization and practice in China. In particular, it seeks to explore the formation of social capital through the dense network of ties that created a community of what the paper calls ‘management intellectuals’, a group whose mission was to promote the modernization of China through the improvement of the management of its industry and commerce. • Irina Potkina - Industrial Assosiations in Late Imperial Russia: Perception, Innovation Process and Public Activity Second half of the 19th century was the time of creation of numerous industrial associations in Russia. Entrepreneurs, engineers and technologists constituted the most active group in the process of coordination of efforts by several social strata to achieve economic prosperity of the country. Business circles created acceptable forms of union — voluntary non-profit societies for the development of industry and commerce or conventions of representatives. There were about 143 associations, and approximately 120 of them were truly public and independent. These organizations had a wide spectrum of functions: representative, innovative, cultural and educational. Main efforts aimed at creation of favorable conditions of industrial development. Entrepreneurial unions played great role in the rapprochement of production process and science, introduction of new technologies, promotion of institutions of higher learning and secondary technical training. Russian voluntary industrial societies developed from simple spokespersons of interests of entrepreneurial groups to active participants of elaboration of principles of domestic economic policy. On the one hand, they should be considered as an element of institutional framework of economic development, and on the other hand, as a sign of formation of civil society in modernizing Russia. • Jonathan Silberstein-Loeb - Association versus joint-stock: the battle for the American news market, 1893-1945 This paper explains why the Associated Press beat the United Press for control of the American news market. It explores the advantages and disadvantages of an associational, as opposed to a joint-stock, business model. It also investigates the relationship between organizational form and property rights in news. The reason for the success of the Associated Press was that its method of organization better protected monopolistic rents than that of the United Press. This protection, however, limited the ability of the Associated Press to innovate. • Paolo Tedeschi - Renewing and Developing the Lombard Industry: the Assolombarda from 1946 to 1968
The aim of this paper is to show how the Assolombarda helped its members in a period including important phases of the European economic history, that is: a) the post-war reconstruction and the Marshall Plan; b) the first steps of the European Integration; c) the Italian “economic miracle” (1958-1963) and the definitive removal of all existing tariffs among the six first countries making the European Common Market (1968). J3 -
Investment and Modern Economy of China since 1840 Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
This session will discuss the capital resources, the change of investment structure and the related financial and monetary systems in modern China. The discussion contains two historical stages, one from 1840 to 1949, and the other from 1949 to 2000. The first stage focuses on the capital resources, investment structure (the resources and departments of investment, industrial and regional structure) and the change of traditional financial systems in the process of modernization. The second stage implores the capital resources of government investment under the plan economy system and the relationship between investment structure and economic growth, the investment structure and capital resources under the market economy system, and the relationship between investment structure and economy development. Further more, the transformation of tradition financial systems is also an important issue. Organizers: • - Wholesale Prices and Economic Growth in Modern China, 1912 -1947
It is well understood that the fluctuations of prices function as the core of the market economy, sending signals to guide a country’s economic development. The complexity of price indexes has forced us to adopt a simple arithmetic average or a simple geometric average as price proxies. • Kent G. Deng - Benchmarking China’s Growth, 1800 to 2000 By using China’s own growth rate in the early 19th century, the findings of this paper reveal that economic growth in China since 1830 was sluggish until 1980. This is the benefit of a long-term approach where the starting point is less arbitrary. In light of this, economic performance of sub-periods (1840 to 1912, 1912 to 1937, 1937 to 1949, 1949 to 1978, and 1980 to 2000) needs re-assessment. • Zhikai Dong - Investment and Industrialization in China in the 1950’s Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
China has a large population and hence abundant supply of cheap labour. This factor determines that China’s capital and technology are relatively more scarce than otherwise. Hence, it makes sense to push the growth of capital formation which is vital for China’s industrialization. This paper analyses conditions and structures of China’s industrialization by looking at China’s labour productivity gap, impact of foreign sanctions after the Korean War and the feasibility of self reliance in capital formation. It also looks at the strategic need for China to adopt a military-industrial growth duet. Participants: • Yun Qu - China’s Foreign Trade and FBI after Deng Xiaoping’s Reform, 1978-2000 Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide China’s foreign trade and FDI inflow took off since 1978. The growth occurred not only on scale, but also on scope. This paper looks at how foreign trade and FDI complement each other. At the first stage from the late 1970s to the early 1990s, reforms facilitated FDI-cum-trade. At the second stage, FDI took the lead with a demonstration effect on China trade model. At the third stage, FDI pushed China to integrate with the global economy and became a dominate factor which influenced China’s government policies. The current bid on domestic consumption aims to strike a balance between FDI and China’s own growth trajectory. • Zhihong Shi - Changes of Traditional Finance in the late Qing's Westernization Movement Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
Since the period of Xianfeng (1851-1861) and Tongzhi (1862-1874), affected by a constant series of important historical events, the financial system of the Qing Dynasty changed a lot in both its administration mode and the contents of income and expenditure. This paper reveals the financial changes taking place under the background of the late Qing’s Westernization Movement, especially focuses on those brought by local governments’ investment in establishing new enterprises such as arsenals, factories and shipyards according to Western models. The main opinion put forward in this paper is that the establishment of a number of new enterprises in provinces during 1860s-1890s by local governments not only changed the content and structure of the Dynasty’s financial income and expenditure, but also produced marked effects on its traditional administration mode. According to the author’s opinion, the late Qing’s Westernization Movement greatly strengthened local governments’ economic and financial position in provinces and played an important role in the process of transformation of financial administration from centralization of authority to the division of power by provinces to a certain degree, which at last formed a relatively independent local financial system in addition to that of the central government. • Baijun Wu • Yi Xu - Taxes and Levies in the Late Qing, 1851-1894 Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide This paper tackles the phenomenon of juan (“contribution” or “donation”) in the late Qing. From the Taiping Rebellion of 1851-1864 to the eve of the Sino-Japanese War of 1894-1895, some provinces collected their own taxes called juan in addition to the lijin or likin tax and customs duty. Gradually, juan became a formal tax instead of informal and spontaneous donation. The juan revenue also became important in supporting official operation at the prefecture, district and county levels. With the juan, the Qing tax resource became localised. • Hongzhong Yan - Development of China’s Finance, 1887-1936
Formation of a modern financial system is a major factor for modernization. This paper discusses the process of China’s financial development and its structural changes from 1887 to 1936 with quantitative indexing. This study suggests that China financial development during 1920s-1930s was still far behind the main capitalism economies. Any further growth faced the financial bottleneck until WWII. • Wei Zhang - Social Capital, Market Integration and Industry Development: A Case of Silk Industry in Yangtze-delta, 1900-1930 Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide Capital can be divided into financial capital, human capital and social capital separately relating to material, knowledge and network needed by industry development. More research on invest and Chinese economy before 1949 were carried on from the aspect of financial capital. This paper explores what and how social capital influence on market integration and industry development. Merchant network is combination of personal networks and organizational networks. There exist different link-patterns based on blood-relationship, geography and common interests among these networks. The more developed market, the more likely the network breaks through the natural ties restrictions such as blood-relationship and geography restriction. Some people argue that those natural link-patterns constraint the market expansion and transformation in modern China. This paper explores the cooperation and conflicts relating to the quality-control and transaction rules among different members of the merchant network in silk industry. The paper finds that “geography” is a crucial factor contributing to strengthen the stability of merchant network and expand the merchant network in a high risky, competitive and separated market. More importantly, those merchant organizations mainly linked by common interests achieve less efficiency than those linked by geography-relationship on cooperating with merchant organization in product place. That is, the latter plays more efficient role in market integration than the former. • Xuejun Zhao - Path Dependence: Transformation of Trade Credit Policy and System in China,1949-2000 Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide China’s trade credit system as a whole is composed of the open account system and the commercial bill system. Until the early of 1950’s, the main body of trade credit in China was the open account trade system. China’s government’s trade credit policy had changed since 1949 to 2000. In the early of 1950’s most trade credits were open accounts, and trade credit system was integrated. In 1954, the Chinese government banned trade credit in order to establish a planned economy. In the early of 1980’s, the government market reform revived the credit system. But there was path dependence on the old system. And, commercial bills were not used extensively. This paper applies new institutional economics to examine why the transformation credit system was so slow. • Jin Zhao - Foreigner’s Real Estate Investment in Modern China Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
A real estate market existed in China’s treaty ports in mid-19th century, and became prosperous in the 1930s. Several factors contributed its growth, including immigration as well as the foreign trade. K3 -
Evolution of Global Paper Industry: 200 years in retrospective Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
In 2003, the value of forest industry production in the world was around 414 billion U.S. Dollars. From this around two thirds was produced within the paper industry. The paper industry has been one of the fastest growing lines of business: whilst at the beginning of the 20th century below ten million tons of paper was produced, in 1995 this figure was 260 million tons. Organizers: • - TWO PAPERS: Nordic Paper Industry AND Pulp and paper in Russia: evolutionary path and a current perspective Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
Development of the Russian pulp and paper industry began later that in other countries in Europe. The first pulp and paper mills in Russia were built in the 19th century, and a significant expansion of the sector began during the Soviet time in 1920s and 1930s. However, pulp and paper industry was never a strategic industry in the Soviet Union. Nowadays, it is getting much more attention, but there are several challenges that it faces in its current phase of development. • Bram Bouwens - Paper and board industry in the Netherlands, 1800-2000 The paper analyses the evolution of the Dutch paper and board industry between 1800 and 2000. After an introduction of the pre-industrial era and the slow process of industrialisation during the 19th century, the paper focus on the development of the industry and the corporate strategies that became apparent during the 20th century. • Tomoko Hashino - The Development of Modern Pulp and Paper Industry in Japan from late 19C to 20C: Rapid Catching-up Process in Modernization Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
This paper focuses on the rapid catch-up process of the Japanese modern pulp and paper industry, which was formed in a completely different course from the traditional handmade paper industry. Japan only started to produce machine paper as late as 1874, but by the 1970s it became the second largest producer in the world. Of course today Japan is a major producer and consumer of paper. As one of the transplanted industries in modern Japan, the pulp and paper industry, mainly established by the private sector, witnessed rapid import substitution, the introduction of advanced foreign technologies, and cartelization from an early stage. The industry experienced export growth during the First World War, and a mega firm occupying 80% domestic paper production was born by amalgamation in 1930s. A main reason for such rapid growth was the enlarged demand for paper in the modernization process of the whole economy. Compared with many other developing countries that used to read books made by washi, a traditional, hand-made paper, the Japanese demand for paper is much higher due to its traditionally high literacy rate. The growth after the Second World War was based on the introduction of advanced technologies, changes in material, diversification of products. The mega firm was dissolved into three firms by GHQ policy. However, today a new wave of M&A has come to this industry. Participants: • Marc de Ferrière le Vayer - French Pulp and Paper industry The story of the French Pulp and Paper industry from the 18th century onward. How one of the most ancient paper industry in Europe couldn't modernize during the 19th century and the first half of the 20th. And how it became a modern and competitive branch after lots of acquisition by foreign companies. • Miquel Gutiérrez Poch - Is there a Southern Europe model? The development of papermaking and pulp industries: Italy, Spain and Portugal (1800-2008)
No one can doubt about the existence of a Scandinavian model in the historical development of papermaking and pulp industries. However, it doesn’t exist any analysis about a general pattern of Southern Europe countries. The aim of this paper is to portray this model trough the analysis of Italy, Spain and Portugal cases. • Juha-Antti Lamberg • Maria Barbosa Lima-Toivanen - Evolution of South American Pulp and Paper Industry: Evolution of South American Pulp and Paper Industry: From forests to becoming a major global player Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
In this chapter, it is discussed the evolution of the South American pulp and paper industry (PPI), with special emphasis on Brazilian and Chilean companies. In these two countries, the industry is well established in terms of operations integration, from forests to pulp mills, and support to innovation activities. The evolution of the industry in other countries, for example in Uruguay and Argentina, will also be discussed, especially because of the profile of new investments carried out in Uruguay and the rise of environmental, which should also be considered as political, claims in the region, due mainly to disagreements between these two last countries concerning the pulp operations and their environmental impact. • Olga Mashkina • Anders Melander • Anders Melander • Timo Sarkka - The Evolution of the British Paper Industry, c. 1800–2000 Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
The history of the British paper industry, for the purposes of this paper, begins in the first half of the nineteenth century. Before that period paper was produced by fairly simple hand processes. In the 1800s started an epoch of mechanical improvements leading multiple changes in the British paper industry. Britain was first country in the world that possessed the capital, the enterprise, and the skill necessary to develop industrial mechanisation. How was then the mechanised production of writing- and printing-paper made a workable economic enterprise in Britain? Such a development would have been impossible without improvements in paper-making techniques and the introduction of paper-making machines. Britain continued to hold a lead in the field of paper-making up until the 1890s after which the momentum of being the first nation successfully to mechanise the production of paper was gradually lost to the overseas competitors. • Hannes Toivanen - Evolution of the U.S. Pulp and Paper Industry since 1860 to the present Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
This article offers a synthesis of the dynamic forces and political economy, which shaped the evolution of pulp and paper industry in the United States since the mid-19th century. In particular, I will attempt to clarify my claim that industry’s evolution in the U.S. should be understood in three successive and distinctive, thoug overlapping, periods, during which different economic, technological and political factors framed firms’ strategic choices and organizational capabilities. • Olli Turunen - The Relative Position and the Development of the German Paper and Pulp Industry, 1800–2000 Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
The first German paper mill was founded in 1390 by Ulmer Stromer in Nürnberg. Once Gutenberg had introduced mechanical printing in the middle of the fifteenth century, humanism and the Protestant Reformation took care of the demand for books and pamphlets creating a flourishing paper industry from the sixteenth century onwards. Now Germany is the top paper producer in Europe and fifth in the world. Due to scarcity of raw material, it is a minor pulp producer and the biggest importer. It consumes almost one fourth of the paper in Europe. Germany developed its distinctive model of capitalism with cooperation, cartels and regulation. In literature, this development is seen through the big business (metal and electric), whereas paper production never concentrated into huge companies like AEG or Siemens. This article focuses on giving a comparison enabling outlook over the German paper and pulp industry in terms of natural and institutional environments, in terms of transition to global economy as also in terms of classical business history claims. Does the development of the German paper and pulp industry conform to the common conceptions about German capitalism? What was the role of technology and science? How did the constantly changing natural and institutional environment shape the German paper industry, which secured its European top position in the early nineteenth century and has since struggled to hold it? Furthermore, the central figures on production, imports and exports, firm population, firm size and prize and accessibility of raw materials are given. L3 -
Street sellers in the early modern world Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
In the history of commerce, street selling is often only marginally treated. In the growing number of publications on early modern trade the focus generally is on merchant trading and on the sale of consumer goods in retail shops. Nevertheless, historians increasingly acknowledge that street vendors and petty traders were an essential feature in the early modern distribution system. Organizers: • - Who owns the streets? Conflict and tolerance amongst street sellers and shopkeepers in early modern Dutch towns
The distribution of consumer goods in early modern towns was by no means a simple affair. Recent research has shown that a complex system of multi-layered distribution networks existed. Commodities were sold at fairs and at daily or weekly markets, in shops, stalls and in small outlets attached to houses or workshops, and on the streets by sellers who went from door-to-door or simply hawked their wares on the main streets and squares. Although each of these commercial circuits could serve a different clientele, it has appeared that very often the various types of vendors competed for the same customers. Tensions amongst the different groups of retailers were therefore not uncommon and could rise very high. • Miki Sugiura - Street Sellers and Street Markets of Early Modern Edo
What were “streets” in street selling? In dealing with street selling and street sellers, it is unavoidable to investigate how streets were historically formed. This paper explores, through comparison of two Early Modern cities Edo and Amsterdam for the longer periods between 1600-1850, the development of streets as urban commercial space and the role of street sellers in relation to it. Participants: • Melissa Calaresu - Selling ice-cream on the streets of eighteenth-century Naples
The history of ice-cream in the early modern period has been dominated by narratives about its origins and its link to luxury consumption in the early modern period. By looking at the practice of selling ice-cream on the streets of Naples, however, it is clear that ice-cream (or sorbetto) was being eaten by a great number of Neapolitans by the end of the eighteenth century. Naples has been closely associated with ice-cream from at least the late seventeenth century as the place of publication of the first book in Europe solely devoted to making sorbetto. Grand Tourists, in turn, made this association, often commenting on the Neapolitan obsession with iced desserts and drinks – so much so, they claimed, that Neapolitans would be more likely to revolt if there was no ice than if there was no grain available in the city. Contemporary engravings suggest the ubiquity of ice-cream sellers on the streets to feed the city’s needs, and, these images of sorbettari have contributed to a picturesque image of the city -- in paintings, porcelain and, later, in photography and urban reportage in the nineteenth century. • Laurence Fontaine • Alberto Grandi - Shop and Street. Haberdashers and Itinerant Rag Merchants in Mantova in the Early Modern
Urban trade in the modern age was generally controlled by guilds. • Shinya Kobayashi • Giorgio Riello - commentator • Jeroen Salman - Street sellers and networks of book distribution in England and the Dutch Republic (17e and 18th century)
Margaret Spufford and Laurence Fontaine have both emphasised the important function of itinerant booksellers as distributors of cheap books in Early Modern Europe. Fontaine concluded that the pedlar, contrary to common notion, was not marginal at all in early modern France. On the contrary, peddling was a vital phenomenon in past communities. This does not only count for the countryside. Paula McDowell has demonstrated the commercial importance of itinerant booksellers in large cities like London in her book The Women of Grubstreet. • Kirsi Vainio-Korhonen - Female street sellers in 18th century Turku (Åbo)
Turku was the biggest contemporary city in 18th century Finland with its 10,000 inhabitants. The livelihood of urban males was based on burgess professions and the associated navigation, on crown and city offices as well as on physical labour performed under the protection of the city. As a rule, an urban woman could manufacture and trade only in goods and services, the sale of which did not require burgess rights; petty retail, textile manufacture and cloth care, as well as accommodation and restaurants. The ”size of company” was small: most of the women only employed themselves. • Ilja Van Damme - Second-hand trade & respectability: a contradictio in terminis? Southern Netherlands, late seventeenth-eighteenth centuries
It is sometimes implicitly suggested that retailing underwent a specific evolution with dramatic turns – or even ‘revolutions’ – changing the basic interactions between buyers and sellers. Already in 1972, the sociologist L.P. Bucklin constructed an almost teleological model where retail institutions are dramatically transformed in response to population pressure and rising consumption budgets. Thus, markets of merchants and ateliers of craftsmen are supposed to be the dominant features of a medieval retail system; the rise of shops becomes specific for the early-modern times; and, finally, retailing is assumed to reach its apex with the rise of modern department stores, chain stores and supermarkets in the nineteenth and twentieth century. M3 -
Banking in Latin America and Europe: a comparative analysis 1880-1980. Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
The role of banking in economic development has been a central question for economic historians. However, little analysis has been made to compare Latin American and European experiences of long-term evolution of banks. We consider crucial to start a comparative research agenda about the historical paths of banking industry from national and context-specific factors. Organizers: • - Between Market and State: the Banco de la Nación Argentina and the building of national public banking in Argentina, 1908-1930 Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide The Banco de la Nación Argentina, created in 1891, over the ashes of two great classic public banks (Banco Nacional, Banco de la Provincia de Buenos Aires ), had at first a discreet existence, dimmed by the enormous weight of private banking, and shackled by the need to differentiate itself from the behaviour of its predecessors following the 1980 crisis. From that date on, a greater freedom of action was possible thanks to the reform of its organic charter and of an increase of its capital, and in a few years it achieved a dominant position in the system, due to the magnitude of its deposits and of its large territorial extent. On the basis of the material available in the same institution (memories, board minutes, etc.), its performance is evaluated beyond those monetary functions pointed out by the specialized literature. Due to credit demands of different productive sectors, previous paths followed in a more "heroic time" by its predecessors of the public banking were resumed. It also played a considerable role in direct or indirect financing of the National State and some of the new public enterprises. Finally, the Banco de la Nación performed a "de facto" regulatory action of the banking system, prior the creation of a Central Bank in the 1930’s. • Albert Broder • Gustavo A. Del Angel - Innovación en el gobierno corporativo y crecimiento en la banca Mexicana. Banco de Comercio 1932-1982. Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide Banco de Comercio fue fundado en 1932 y en pocos años se convirtió en el segundo banco más importante del México. Hoy es el mayor banco del país, y la filial más importante del grupo multinacional español BBVA. El crecimiento original del banco estuvo fundamentado en una estrategia de expansión regional a través de la formación de una red de filiales regionales, uno modelo tomado de experiencias europeas. Este modelo constituyó una innovación en los mercados bancarios mexicanos y transformó a la industria bancaria. En sus orígenes Banco de Comercio estaba controlado por un grupo de accionistas que mantenían un equilibrio en el control corporativo. En 1957 el banco sufrió un takeover hostil por parte de uno de los accionistas, un caso sin precedentes en México. El control quedó centralizado en el nuevo presidente del banco, y se unificó la red de filiales como un sistema integrado. En 1975, con la ley de banca múltiple los 35 bancos que formaban la red se fusionaron en una sola entidad, constituyendo el mayor banco de América Latina. • Carles Sudria Participants: • Luis Anaya Merchant • Bernardo Batiz-Lazo • Roberto Cortes Conde - The monetary and banking reforms during de 1930 crisis
The 2008 crisis has renewed interest in the crash of 1929 and the Great Depression of the 30s • José Luis García-Ruiz - Banks and the Rise of Corporate Business in 20th Century Spain
A prominent issue in theory and history of finance is about the convenience or not of a tight bank-industry relationship. Should the banks be promoters of industrial firms? Are there any advantages in the control of those firms by the banks? This kind of operations favours the strategic interests of the industry or the short-term interests of the banks? At the end, is it indifferent that the firms were financed with internal resources (capital) or with the external ones (credit), as the simplest classical model supports? • Michel Lescure - French banks during the 19th century (1860-1913) Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
The paper studies the strategy and the role of French banks in comparison with the German and English banks. It is grounded on the balance sheet data of a large sample of banks collected by French and international institutions . • Pablo Martin Aceña - WHY FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS GO ABROAD: THE CASE OF THE BANCO DE SANTANDER IN LATIN AMERICA
WHY FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS GO ABROAD: THE CASE OF THE BANCO DE SANTANDER IN LATIN AMERICA • Pablo Martin Aceña - FINANCIAL CRISES AND FINANCIAL REFORMS IN SPAIN: WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED? Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
FINANCIAL CRISES AND FINANCIAL REFORMS IN SPAIN: WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED? • Adolfo Meisel - Inflation and Central Bank Autonomy in Latin America: The Colombian Experience, 1923-2008
This paper explores the relationship between central bank independence and inflation in Latin America using the experience of Colombia in the period 1923-2008 as a case study. Colombia is interesting in this respect, since it has one of the oldest central banks in Latin America, which since its creation, in 1923, has gone through several major reforms that have changed its objectives and degree of independence. During the period 1923-1951, the central bank was private and independent, with a strong legal commitment to price stability. However, in the period 1951-1991, that commitment was reduced through several legal reforms. For example, in 1963 the monetary responsibilities were divided between a government-dominated monetary board, which oriented monetary policy, and the central bank, which carried them out. In the early 1990s, the bank recovered its independence and its focus on price stability. Inflation varied substantially during the different subperiods of the bank´s institutional history. The review of the Colombian experience shows that independence of the central bank combined with a commitment to price stability renders the best results in terms of price stability. • M. Angeles Pons - FINANCIAL CRISES AND FINANCIAL REFORMS IN SPAIN: WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED?
The current international financial crisis, initiated in the United States market and followed by worldwide turbulence, has raised concern about the fragility of the financial system, and reveals the difficulties in implementing measures and legislation to prevent economic turmoil. The works of Bordo (2007, 2008), Reinhart and Rogoff (2008), Eichengreen (2008) or Felton and Reinhart (2008), among others, have tried to use economic history to understand financial crises, the causes behind them and their consequences, an also to find answers to the questions of how to prevent financial crises in the future, and how to counteract financial turbulence when it appears. Can history help policy makers to design a better regulatory system? Can the past provide guide to enhance the effectiveness of prudential regulation? • André Straus - The factors of bank liqidity in France 1958-1973
In this paper, we present the results of the first step of a study which try to measure the efficiency and the limits of the Banque of France’s intervention on the bank system’s liquidity between 1958 and 1973. Ability of central banks to control and regulate is among the key questions concerning the banking systems. Monetary policy operating procedures have continuously changed in the light of modifications in the structure and workings of financial markets as well as in the broader economic and political environment. intervention on the bank system’s • Romain Thiebaud - The factors of bank liquidity in France 1958-1973
In this paper, we would present the results of the first step of a study which try to measure the efficiency and the limits of the Banque of France’s intervention on the bank system’s liquidity between 1958 and 1973. Ability of central banks to control and regulate is among the key questions concerning the banking systems. Monetary policy operating procedures have continuously changed in the light of modifications in the structure and workings of financial markets as well as in the broader economic and political environment. In this paper we present the first results of a study which try to measure the efficiency and its limits of the Banque of France’s intervention on the bank system’s liquidity between 1958 and 1973 N3 -
The emergence of socioeconomic differences in mortality, 18th to 20th century Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
While it is widely recognized that the socioeconomic differences in health and mortality today are substantial, it remains an open question how large they were in the past. While some scholars have seen convergence others believe that socioeconomic differences in mortality were small in the past, but widened during the first phase of the mortality transition. This session will focus on long-term trends in socioeconomic differences in mortality from the 18th century onwards. We welcome contributions relating to a variety of settings and regions, from researchers in both developed and developing countries. Papers may be country-specific or comparative. Especially encouraged are contributions on the changes over time in the relationship between mortality, social class and gender, on the relationship between locality and social class differences in mortality, including studies using multi-level and event history models that account for temporal variations of contextual effects and papers that will account for the temporal variations of the contextual effects over long periods of time. We are interested in the mechanisms between socioeconomic position and mortality, i.e. whether the gradient is due to income and wealth, housing, education, etc. We also are interested in the way in which the academic and political world historically has stimulated research in this field and or reacted to research findings. Contributions might be based on re-analysis of published statistical data, on analyses on newly-collected information from micro-data and on more qualitative sources. Organizers: • - Socioeconomic Status and Mortality during the Mortality Transition: A Micro-level Study of Age-specific Mortality in Rural Southern Sweden 1815-1894
Socioeconomic differences in health and mortality is a crucial indicator of inequality in well-being. While it is widely recognized that such differences in mortality today are substantial most evidence indicate that they were only modest in the past. This paper examines the emergence of socioeconomic differences in age-specific mortality during the period of mortality decline in the nineteenth and early twentieth century. It uses multilevel Cox regression controlling for unobserved heterogeneity at the family level, and also estimate the quantitative importance of this heterogeneity. Longitudinal micro-level data for an economically transforming rural area in southern Sweden during the period 1815-1940 is used, and occupations are coded and classified using international standards (HISCO, HISCLASS). Together with information of landholding and from the beginning of the 20th century on income at individual level, this provides high quality information on social position. • Tommy Bengtsson Participants: • Marco Breschi • Sören Edvinsson - Wealth and Health in 19th Century Sweden. A Study of Social Differences in Adult Mortality in the Sundsvall Region
In this paper we analyse social differences in mortality in the Sundsvall region during the 19th century. Our study relates to scholarly discussions about the role of social inequality as determinants for health in historical contexts. A common assumption is that such differences have persisted throughout history even at different levels. Others have suggested that there has been a transition from an old mortality pattern where geography was the main determinant to a situation where social class has become the most important variable. Empirical studies on this are however few and point in different directions. • Allesio Fornasin • Alain Gagnon - Social differences in mortality and social mobility in the Saguenay-Lac-Saint-Jean region of Quebec (19th – 20th centuries) According to Link and Phelan’s theory of the “fundamental social causes of disease,” inequalities in access to resources such as knowledge, money, prestige, and social connections would always lead to inequalities in health and mortality. No matter what diseases or what risks happen to exist at a particular time, the wealthiest would always use their advantage to avoid risks and to adopt strategies that enhance health and longevity. This paper seeks to test this theory with data from a population going through the industrial revolution, the 19th – 20th century Saguenay-Lac-Saint-Jean region in Quebec. The data consist of birth, marriage, and death certificates extracted from the BALSAC database (Université du Québec à Chicoutimi), which comprehensively traces the demographic history of the region since the beginning of its peopling in 1840 up to the early 1970s. We use a categorisation of social position consisting of five occupation-based statuses, which summarizes the nearly 4,000 different occupations mentioned in the registers: 1-White collars (including executives, industrialists, and liberal professions); 3- Farmers; 3- Artisans (craftsmen, specialized workers); 4- Lower-skilled workers (carpenters, etc.), and 5- Unskilled Workers (laborers, factory workers, etc.). In the first part of our analysis, we use a person-period data structure with a time-varying codification of occupations in order assess the impact of occupation on mortality until the age of 60. Controlling for year of birth, age at marriage, residence patterns, and literacy, we found lower mortality among farmers and artisans than among all the other categories. If anything, white-collars had the highest mortality of all. This contradicts the numerous reports of a lower mortality at higher levels of the social hierarchy. The critical factor could be the exposure to toxic environmental conditions that were shared by white collars and their employees during the active life stage. Away from the factories and industries, artisans and farmers would have benefited from a “better air.” In the second part, we study mortality from age 60 to cohort extinction for individuals born before 1875. We used the modal values of the variables of interest at age 60 to assess cumulated experience in a given status, with results that largely parallel mortality before age 60. However, when using the last occupation prior age 60 (instead of the modal category), no significant difference was found between white collars and farmers, and lower-skilled and unskilled workers were now found to have the highest mortality, as one would expect. Upward social mobility could account for this striking reversal of effect. Our results also emphasize the role of literacy as an important predictor of mortality. Those who could not sign their name on the parish register early in their adult life had mortality rates that were 2.5-3 times higher than those who could, whatever their occupation. • Bernard Harris • Anton Kunst • Marie Lindkvist • Matteo Manfredini - Socioeconomic conditions, health and mortality from birth to early adulthood, Alghero 1856-1925 This work deals with the role of socioeconomic conditions on health status and mortality between birth and full maturity in the Sardinian community of Alghero. Data come from civil sources as well as from military conscription registers and cover the 1856 and 1925. Reconstruction of individual life-histories for three generations from birth to 25 years was carried out. In view of information richness of the military documentation (occupation, anthropometric data, health status and education level), the analysis was focused on the male population. Besides the analysis of the selection process from birth to full maturity, these data allow to assess the death risk between 20 and 25 years taking into account health status and socioeconomic conditions at conscription as well as information on father’s health status at his own enrollment. • Stanislao Mazzoni • Michel Oris - Social mortality differentials in Geneva. A comparison over four centuries • Richard Steckel • Frans van Poppel - Social class, social mobility and mortality in the Netherlands, 1850-2007
This study uses data from a random sample of births in the Netherlands during the period 1850-1922 to examine the relationships between social class, social mobility and mortality at middle and old age. Population registers and personal cards covering the period from 1850 to 2006 for all Dutch provinces were used to reconstruct individual life histories of more than 15,000 births. We study the effects of the social class of origin and own social class (using two different SES-classifications) on mortality after age 18 for men and women. P3 -
Money as commodity Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
The “settling of the balance of payments” concept that is commonplace in the literature, explains for much of the transportation of significant sums of money throughout the centuries. Alternatively, it is interesting to explore more deeply the motivation of the coin-paying side, when there were extra profits to be gained by using specific forms of cash payments. Sometimes benefits arose because of avoiding the burdens associated with non-monetary commodities, but in other cases enhanced profits stemmed directly from the availability (and the price!) of specific kinds of monies themselves. In such cases, attention needs to be focused on the choice of specific monies used. This phenomenon is not concerned with deferred (future) profits due to later sale of the usual trade goods, but with immediate profits realized by paying one specific kind of money rather than others. Organizers: • • Marcel Van der Beek - The use of low alloy silver coins in silver transit states Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
People use to move silver around the world for profit. In countries where the metal passes by, all the existent silver (including the stock of silver coins) tends to be exported and to follow the silver flow. In times of metal coin standard such a state was deprived of the coins that were necessary for most daily transactions. Participants: • Sushil Chaudhury - European Companies' Bullion and the Indian Money Market - Challenges and Responses - Early Modern Era
It is common knowledge that the European Companies had to bring in bullion, whether in bars or coins, to India for procuring the export commodities for Europe as Europe then had nothing to offer which could be sold profitably and in large quantities in the Indian market so as to earn profits with which they could have paid for the purchases for Europe. But even in doing so they had to face lot of challenges and difficulties in converting the bullion into local currencies as neither silver bars nor various coins exported by the Companies were accepted by the merchants or primary producers for the goods sold. Here in this paper I shall try to examine the challenges and difficulties faced by the Companies and their responses as also how the money markets behaved in the face of huge influx of bullion in the train of European trade. For such analysis I shall mainly focus on the scenario in Bengal as it was the chief partner of the European trade in the early modern era.. It will be shown that the Companies were at the mercy of the House of Jagat Sehts, the biggest banker of the then world, as they had to depend largely on the this house for converting the bullion into local currencies. The Mughal mint was free in principle which meant that anyone could coin/convert money in the mints. Bur what happened in actual practice was that by virtue of its great hold on the ruling authority of Bengal, the house had a virtual monopoly of the use of the mint. Thus it could easily thwart the Companies’ attempt to coin in the mint which would force them, as they were always in chronic shortage of liquid capital, to sell their bullion in the money market, which was again dominated by the Jagat Seths, at a price much lower than the market price. It will be shown with evidence from Company records how they tried to face the challenge and how they responded to the situation but mostly with little success • Dennis Flynn - A Price Theory of Monies It is best to approach monetary by disaggregating individual monies to the maximum extent possible. It is a mistake to lump diverse monies together. Moreover, individual monies need not fulfill all three monetary functions (medium of exchange, unit of account, and store of value). This essay takes disaggregation a step further, and argues that there are two distinct types of unit-of-account-only monies: (1) the imaginary monies used for accounting purposes, and (2) a ratio-unit-of-account money that serves a crucial role in a proposed Price Theory of Money. This Price Theory of Money (PTM) differs fundamentally from all Quantity Theories of Money, and is far more useful than normal QTMs for understanding monetary history and economic theory generally. • Akinobu Kuroda - Silvers valued by silver: how the silver tael system in China really worked? The usage of un-coined silver in traditional China was based on imaginary monetary units in terms of silver weight. In other words, the weight did not directly represent any weight of actual silver ingot. The word, silver tael or liang, was used in both ways of actually weighing ingots and imaginarily calculating values. Account books by Chinese merchants reveals that, in most cases, silver tael functioned as standard of value, while, silver ingots were rarely handed in transactions. Meanwhile, regardless of foreign or domestic, silver coins were valued by an imaginary tael, and their prices fluctuated according to demand/supply day by day, as same as other currencies including copper coins. Most studies on Chinese economic history failed to distinct imaginary silver unit from actual silver currencies. • Petr Vorel - Major developments in silver trade in Central and Eastern Europe in 16th and 17th century (The comparison of function of Bohemian and Polish coins in monetary circulation abroad)
The author observes shifts in silver trade, which took place in the region of Central and Eastern Europe due to then passing political and economic changes. He compares the function of two diferent coinage systems in monetary circulation of Central and Eastern Europe in 16th and 17th century, namely the Kingdom of Bohemia and Kingdom of Polonia. Up to the half of the 16th century Bohemia was a very important exporter of silver. The majority of silver traded by Bohemia was supplied to the market in form of thaler coinage. These coins were subject of direct long-distance trade with Eastern Europe and were also used as a commodity for production of local means of payment used in baltic trade, Poland and Russia. The Bohemian currency (groats and bits) had no significance for European monetary circulation as opposed to the Polish currency in the 17th century. The silver imported from overseas in form of dutch coins begins to dominate the Baltic and East European silver market since the beginning of the 17th century. These coins were commonly used in large quantities as a commodity for coining of local Polish means of payment, which were further exported to neighbouring areas of Central Europe and Ottoman Empire. The author is explaining diffences between the Bohemian exportable system of coinage based on own sources of precious metal but with limited use of its currency outside the country on one side and the Polish distributional coinage system without these sources of precious metal but with a good usability of its currency abroad on the other side. • Willem Wolters - Money transfers by bills of exchange and bullion and silver shipments in East and Southeast Asia in the second half of the 19th century (under a system of multilateral exchange rates) In the second half of the 19th century the multilateral exchange system, based on the use of the bill of exchange (established in Europe in the 17th century), had been extended to the trading ports and towns in Asia. The value of coins and the price of silver in these places was determined by the premiums and discounts on exchange rates, with the London rates as the ultimate reference point. The paper will discuss the different circuits and different modes of money transfers, focussing on two countries: Netherlands India and the Philippine Islands. In the 1850s and 1860s the Netherlands government sent large amount of silver coins to Batavia, from where these coins quickly disappeared to neighbouring countries, viz., British India and Singapore. In the late 1870s and early 1880s the Spanish government in the Philippine Islands saw the gold currency disappear from the islands. In the last decades of the 19th century large flows of silver coins (mainly Mexican dollars) were imported to or exported from the Philippine Island, in contravention of the exchange rate logic. The paper will explore the question to what extent it is useful to distinguish different money circuits or spheres of exchange during this period. • Giovanni Zanalda - The zecchino as commodity. Monetary and non-monetary factors behind the demand for Venetian zecchini in the East in the 17th century. The Venetian golden ducat, zecchino, had acquired in the course of several centuries the status of "international currency", circulating and exchanged in territories outside the control of the Venetian Republic. The analysis of seventeenth-century sources, from travel accounts (Jean-Baptiste Tavernier’s Les six voyages de Jean-Baptiste Tavernier, Ecuyer Baron D’Aubonne, qu’il a fait en Turquie, en Perse, et aux Indes … Paris, 1676) to treatises on money (Geminiano Montanari’s Breve Trattato… Venice, 1683), reveals that the zecchino despite the decline of Venice commercial presence and power in the East still commanded a high premium in Asia, from Turkey to India. On the basis of seventeenth-century sources, this paper analyzes the dual role of zecchino, money and commodity, and the policy implications for Venice. Q3 -
Responses of economic systems to environmental change: past experiences Session abstract: Show Session abstract: Hide
The impact of environmental changes on human well-being has been well documented in numerous case studies that examined how exogenous shocks such as climate anomalies, changes in rainfall patterns, the spread of new strains of pests and diseases, or large scale volcanic eruptions resulted in catastrophic events (famines, epidemic, etc.) and in some cases durable disruption of economic conditions and a drastic decline of the standard of living. Often these studies lack a rigorous assessment of how economic systems responded to such exogenous shocks. Organizer: • - Rainfall, the Méline tariff, and wheat production in Mediterranean France, 1885-1914 Domestic wheat production remained fairly stable in France in the late 19th and early 20th century, but cultivated acreage and output volumes declined sharply around the Mediterranean during the 1870s and early 1880s. In this region, wheat output never recovered to its previous level in the following years despite the introduction, from 1885, of repeated and enhanced tariff barriers, such as the 1892 Méline Tariff, which imposed duties on imported agricultural products. The purpose of this paper is to analyse the response of Mediterranean wheat producers to changes in local rainfall and variation of duties on imported grains. We use regional level data for 9 administrative divisions (départements) located on or near the Mediterranean (Pyrénées Orientales, Aude, Hérault, Gard, Vaucluse, Bouches-du-Rhône, Var, Alpes Maritimes, and Corse). We assess the impact of rainfall on yields and investigate whether protectionist policy interplayed with environmental conditions as a determinant of acreage under wheat cultivation. Participants: • Marc Badia Miró • Jean-Pierre Dormois - Rainfall, the Méline tariff and domestic wheat production in Mediterranean France 1885-1914 Domestic wheat production remained fairly stable in France during the late 19th and early 20th century, but cultivated acreage and output volumes declined sharply around the Mediterranean during the 1870s and early 1880s. In this region, wheat output never recovered to its previous level in the following years despite the introduction, from 1885, of repeated and enhanced tariff barriers, such as the 1892 Méline Tariff, which imposed duties on all major agricultural staples. The purpose of this paper is to analyse the response of Mediterranean wheat producers to changes in local rainfall and variation of duties on imported grains. We use regional level data for 9 administrative divisions (départements) located on or near the Mediterranean (Pyrénées Orientales, Aude, Hérault, Gard, Vaucluse, Bouches-du-Rhône, Var, Alpes Maritimes, and Corse) in order to assess the impact of rainfall on yields and investigate whether protectionist policy interplayed with changes in environmental conditions as a determinant of acreage under wheat cultivation. • Janet Hunter - Nature, Markets and State Response: the Drought of 1939 in Japan and Korea Through much of 1939-early 1940 large areas of Northeast Asia experienced rainfall significantly below the normal level. Some contemporaries said that the persistent drought was unequalled in its severity since the late 18th century. The main impact of the drought in Korea was on agricultural production and the livelihoods of the farming population. The shortfall in rain did not lead to famine in Japan, or even malnutrition, but it nevertheless had a significant impact on the operation of parts of the Japanese economy, in particular the markets for some key commodities. The presentation will consider these impacts, and also the response of the state to the problems generated by the drought. It will be suggested that analysis of the drought demonstrates some unexpected linkages between markets, while the response of the authorities exposed a lack of contingency planning for such natural disasters, as well as a willingness to use them to cover for other problems. In the process, the drought also accelerated the move of Japan’s economic system towards a managed economy. • Harry Kitsikopoulos - Theoretical debates on the crisis of the early 14th century: Ricardian dynamics vs. the role of weather and microbes The first major debate regarding the economic and social forces that shaped the dynamic of the feudal system was initiated with an article by Robert BRENNER (“Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-Industrial Europe,” Past and Present, 70, [1976]). It presented an argument that was inspired by Marxist theory and came to challenge Michael M. Postan’s population-resources or Neo-Malthusian argument. POSTAN responded, with John HATCHER (“Population and Class Relations in Feudal Society,” Past and Present, 78, [1978]). The interest sparked by this exchange continued with a number of additional contributions, including a final response by BRENNER (“The Agrarian Roots of European Capitalism,” Past and Present, 97 [1982]). The latter, along with the two original articles, were published as a collection of essays (Trevor H. ASTON and C. H. E. PHILPIN, eds., The Brenner Debate: Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-Industrial Europe, 1987). A third interpretation was formulated by Bruce Campbell in a series of publications, beginning in the 1990s, that came to be known as the Commercialist or Thunenesque approach. The review that follows will provide a critical summary of these three competing theoretical paradigms by contrasting their claims against the existing empirical evidence. • Jonathan Liebowitz - Overcoming Crisis in Late Nineteenth Century French Agriculture
A series of blows, ranging from diseases and disastrous weather to greatly expanded imports, struck French agriculture in the late 19th century, ending a period of prosperity. Farmers reacted to preserve their livelihoods in a variety of ways. Some focused on the damage brought by imports and sought protection through tariffs. Others shifted to new products that would face less competition. Still others relied on the flexibility provided by their tenure system to soften the blows of the crisis. Many used several approaches to ensure their survival. • Maria Eugénia Mata - Environmental Challenge in the Canning Industry Fish-canning industries are closely-linked to, and have an impact on environmental conditions, bringing great challenges to optimality. While entrepreneurship perspectives focus on the survival and profitability of firms, social utility perspectives focus on collective welfare and long-term sustainability. This paper illustrates the theoretical puzzle of the fish-canning industry in examining the historical experience of Portuguese public policies from the point of view of industrial economics and collective welfare. • Tirthankar Roy - ‘The Law of Storms’: European and Indigenous Response to Natural Disasters in Early Modern India Paper summary: Show Paper summary: Hide
The lower Bengal delta, which has among the most fertile soil conditions in the world for paddy cultivation, is also susceptible to violent October cyclonic storms, accompanied by tsunamis. Some of these episodes destroyed habitats over very large territories, which were repopulated relatively quickly despite the huge risks. How did states and societies perceive and adapt to these risks? Archival and documentary evidence from the nineteenth century suggest two distinct patterns of response, a relatively new one that took shape within the context of the Indo-European state and settlement in the region, and a traditional one that had been present already in the context of the Indian regimes and peasant societies. The former sought to discover the ‘law of storms’ (the title of an early scientific treatise on climatic patterns in the Bay of Bengal) and thus measure the risks, and the latter involved large-scale embankment projects to stave off storm surges. How do we understand the difference? • Enric Tello - THE GRAPE PHYLLOXERA PLAGUE AS A NATURAL EXPERIMENT: THE UPKEEP OF VINEYARDS IN CATALONIA (SPAIN, 1858-1935) We present a comparative analysis of the impact and outcome in Catalonia of the wine rush and crash unleashed by the spread of the Grape Phylloxera plague in Europe (1865-1890). In order to explain why many rural districts in the provinces of Barcelona and Tarragona were able to resume winegrowing after the plague, while most in the provinces of Girona and Lleida were not, a statistical model is used to check the economic resilience of the Catalan districts to the external ecological and economic shock. The model combines the population densities as a proxy of the opportunity cost in labour allocation, the demand pull of commercial growth measured by the time-distances to the city of Barcelona, and the agro-climatic land’s suitability for growing vines, as measured by the Hugling and Winkler indices or the mean slopes of land. After comparing the vineyard allocation in every district in 1860, 1889 and 1920, these variables are used to explain the differing capacities to endure the Phylloxera plague in Catalonia.
|
|
|
||